The bonds between Naomi and Ely are tested when they fall for the same guy.
Victoria Justice
Naomi Mills
Pierson Fodé
Ely Diamond
Matthew Daddario
Gabriel
Ryan Ward
Bruce 2
Griffin Newman
Bruce 1
Monique Coleman
Girl-Robin
Danny Flaherty
Boy-Robin
Gary Betsworth
Mr. McAllister
Dean Kapica
George
Marianne Hagan
Mom-Susan
Maddie Corman
Mom-Ginny
Petronia Paley
Mrs. Loy
Kathy Tong
Cassandra
Kevin Abernethy
Club Goer
Connor Antico
Dude is Boxer
Ali Skye Bennet
Carrie Wannabe
Charles Cain
Young Ely
AJ Cedeno
Barista
Spike Christie
Naomi's Dad
Michael DeMello
Bouncer
David Eggers II
College Student
Olamide Faison
Otis
Najee Griffin
Basketball Player
Miki Hanta
Stir Fry Girl
Cindy Ho
Party Girl
Kevin Ho
Lily James
Young Naomi
Salma Khan
Tural Manafov
Gianna Marino
Party Goer
Juliette Marotta
Wedding Guest
Shane Mehigan
Basketball Player / Party DJ
Kurt Meier
Teen Ely
Heather Merkel
Young Mother
Makayla Merkel
Young Daughter
Roy Nowlin
Dorsea Palmer
Rich Kid
Jillian Pedone
Teen Naomi
Doug Plaut
R.A.
Portia
Professor
Robyn Pugh
Coffee Shop Patron
Madison Riley
Dakota
Sergi Robles
Teacher's Assistant
Jacinto Romero
Afro Guy
Kristen Romond
Michael Ruggiere
Water Balloon Guy
Lucas Saiter
I.A.Y.B. Guy
Cliff Samara
Mahmood
Jason B. Schmidt
Very Gay Guy
Casey Smith
Stoner
Eshita Starr
Bakery Customer / Party Girl / Student
Will Torres
Karaoke bar patron
Tashiana Washington
Tennesse
Roger Yeh
Geeky Guy
Benjamin Eakeley
Wanker Banker
Alanna Fox
Cheesy Girl
Andi Matichak
Montana
